In 1981 Petersen was speeding over the limit during a foggy night and ran over a young woman (Gina) who had just been in a minor motorcycle collision with her two male companions. "I just wanted to reach out with disgust at how your department handled the Steven Avery case. If Petersen was willing to go that far God only knows what else happened that hasn't yet come to light. So Petersen takes the initiative to threaten Kakatsch with arrest if she should try and access the scene to do her job (Kakatsch eventually quit after Steven was convicted due to fearing for her safety). Manitowoc County is now officially on the map for having the most corrupt (law enforcement officers) in the nation, congrats. Dogs don't lie, and this was a cadaver dog alert (scent of death) PLUS a bloodhound alert (scent of Teresa). Id run the grave risk of being arrested for arson and armed robbery before my tank was filled with gasoline. Justice is no longer served to all impartially, but abused and obstructed at will - and that's exactly how Manitowoc County became the cesspool of corruption it was in 2005, and why the integrity of Steven's 2007 conviction must be examined once more. From Zellner's investigative instincts to Avery's current standing in the court system to a detailed analysis of the accusations against former prosecutor Ken Kratz, Ferak covers a variety of new angles in the book and expands on the key points that make the case so polarizing. This is PART TWO in a three part series of posts concerning the troubling history of Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department as detailed by Jxxx Ferak in his book "Wrecking Crew." Obligatory: Any factual inaccuracies are mine, not Ferak's. Here is a link to PART ONE: Fuck-ups, Cover-ups and Promotions, largely concerning Sheriff Kocourek and his repeated promotions to inexperienced new hires . Anonymous announced that it would get involved in the legal dispute between the Manitowoc County Sheriff Department and Steven Avery, the star . And justice was served.. I see him leading a laid-back life and enjoying the solitude. It wasn't long before members of the community were whispering about a police cover-up, and this included Ricky's mother and father, who both had troubling run-ins with the department after their son's death. People that are passing judgment on just the facts in that film, I think theyre way off base. Your department is a JOKE. Here is a link to PART ONE: Fuck-ups, Cover-ups and Promotions, largely concerning Sheriff Kocourek and his repeated promotions to inexperienced new hires, Petersen and Bushman, who both happened to be involved in (separate) grossly negligent on-duty traffic accidents that were quickly swept under the rug by Kocourek. The Hermann father helped elect Kocourek as Sheriff - and as Sheriff Kocourek would go on to repeatedly promote Petersen (See Part One). Seems about right. This is PART TWO in a three part series of posts concerning the troubling history of Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department as detailed by Jxxx Ferak in his book "Wrecking Crew." The Hermann boys was saved, largely thanks to Bushman, although everyone helped, including then Sheriff Kocourek, who downright refused assistance from the Wisconsin State Patrol's Technical Crash Reconstruction Experts (Pg. Again, Ferak theorizes Kocourek was steadily promoting those whose involvement in serious incidents he helped down play, such as Petersens running over a citizen, or Bushmans driving through an intersection at high speed and decently wrecking his squad car. Unfortunately threats and intimidation are often effective. The Hermanns were a critical feature of Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department, with at least 3 members of the same immediate family having worked at the department throughout the years, starting in 1962. For example, Coroner Kakatsch quit her position as County Coroner after Steven and Brendan were convicted, telling the filmmakers through watery eyes although she loved her job she didnt feel safe working in the position any longer. He pointed to the portrayal of Manitowoc County Sheriff's Sgt. It was getting tainted by the minute.. A civil lawsuit victory for Steven Avery was undoubtedly a loss for not only Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department, but the DOJ and Attorney General as well. Neither Steven nor his lawsuit had a snowflake's chance in hell if the authorities were willing to disregard their own laws in order to manipulate evidence and destroy crime scenes. In this case, surely the state knew to expect intense adversarial challenges if they were going to arrest Steven Avery. In the interest of explaining just how tangled this web is, I review the many, many familiar or social connections between the Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department, Calumet County Sheriff's Department, and the Wisconsin Department of Justice. This solidified his family's position of power and influence in the community. Among other things, Petersen told reporters Steven "could be a con man" (false and inflammatory) that he burned a cat alive (false and inflammatory) and that if he wasn't convicted of Teresa's murder he would kill AGAIN (speculative and inflammatory). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Christ almighty that pissed me off. All evidence points towards the incompetence of your department I hope and pray your department and local police and that judge are found out, and YOU rot in jail. But then, all of a sudden, the crime lab declared nothing was found, and everyone went home. Sloppy work, really, from MCSD. This needlessly destructive method of recovery ensured no meaningful examination could ever take place. Halbachs cell phone and camera were found burnt in a burn barrel. "I am sure that after you are all exposed, you will not feel any regret for putting an innocent man in prison for the majority of his life; I am sure the only regret you will feel is that of being caught. I truly feel sorry for the residents of your county who will be judged according to the actions of a few. No mention of the accident or fatality can be found Petersens employment file or in any of his promotion notices. He takes all of my evidence, expert opinions and theories and really examines them in detail," Zellner said. Eventually, citizens began discussing the possibility of a police cover-up, including Ricky's mother and father. 1,070 were here. Everyone Practices Cancel Culture | Opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | Opinion, Kathleen Zellner Files New Request For DNA Tests, Ken Kratz Offered Free Brain Fingerprinting, 'Making A Murderer' Part 2: Best New Evidence. After arriving at the hit and run scene Officer Bushman quickly called the older Hermann brother, an off-duty Lieutenant, and asked that he come to the scene. Notably, both cadaver dogs and bloodhounds independently made their way to the scene, which meant the burial site was emanating the scent of decomposition as well as Teresa's scent, likely because her decomposing remains were present at the burial site. On November 7, 2005 Bushman and the younger Hermann brother signed in together at the command post. At this time, no further follow-up will need to be done.". It is an honor to serve the citizens of Manitowoc County and to work with a dedicated staff of professionals. Her criticism echoed thatof other residents, and the prosecutor and law enforcement involved in the case. And no, the state has not and probably never will provide any semblance of sound reasoning to explain why cadaver and bloodhounds both alerted at the burial site if the scene was not connected to Teresa's death. I'm pretty sure at some point, Steven Avery's conviction will be overturned. Tadych publicly protested Brendan's innocence, but Tadych also remains under suspicion for her defense of Bobby Dassey, Brendan's brother, who implicated the once-exonerated Steven Avery as the State's star witness, (Ferak, Appleton Post-Crescent). It's a grossly obstructive act that SCREAMS BAD FAITH. As it turns out Schetter grew up with the Hermann boys in Manitowoc County, even serving as a groomsman at the younger Hermann brothers wedding (Pg. Those responsible for this miscarriage of justice the countless employees of Manitowoc who acted illegally, who lied, and who turned a blind eye to the unethical actions of their peers all deserve to burn in hell. The vast majority of the emailswere harshly critical andsuggested the sheriff'sdepartment consists of crooked cops. Among the missing evidence Hermann cited: The comments that evidence was planted is just not practical. This burial site fiasco likely culminated in MCSD planting the bones in Steven's burn pit. Why would they collect critical evidence without properly tagging or taking photos? And although it's a big topic of conversation, she said, most people here are talking about the documentary itself, notdebating whether the men actually committed the crime. In 1999 the Hermann brothers (the ones who worked at MCSD) became unofficial suspects in a vehicular homicide of Ricky Hotchstetler, a case for which Sheriff Kocourek named Bushman as lead investigator. "Some of the emails, in my opinion, have been borderline threatening. Both Petersen and Bushman were hired by MCSD with no prior experience in law enforcement; both were in serious collisions in their squad cars; both became loyal underlings to Sheriff Kocourek; and both names turn up during the 1985 Penny Bernsteen assault case, the 1999 Ricky Hotchstetler vehicular homicide case, and the 2005 Teresa Halbach criminal homicide case. 163): "I (Sgt. ", 11. Although a coroner determined Gina Hxxxxx died before being run over by Petersens squad car, such an opinion would ideally be backed up by a thorough investigation. Bushman knew the Hermann family well enough to list the Hermann father as a reference on his application to MCSD (Pg. This is just kind of a blip in the history of the world. Only loyalists are hired and promoted and well meaning officers either burn out or are forced out. I see him wearing old tattered blue jeans, tank tops and sandals. After everything, MCSD escaped facing civil liability and a family was forced to say goodbye to their daughter. They have to realize the separation between a museum and a judicial issue. I can, however, now look my children in the eyes and say, 'at least we dont live in Wisconsin. So yes, both the MCSD and Wisconsin DOJ wanted Steven's lawsuit to fail more than they wanted justice to be served to Teresa and her family. Bushman was totally unaware he was approaching an intersection, it seems, and was looking in his rear view mirror long enough with such focus that he drove right through the intersection and off the road at highway speed! They only arrived at or around 3 p.m. Bushman, Colborn and Lenk had plenty of time to fuck with the scene or make evidence disappear. I think if it documented everything correctly and wouldnt have downplayed some of the key points, the response would have been totally different. The DOJ's criminal destruction of an apparent crime scene is extremely telling. Manitowoc County Drug Disposal Program is accepting unused and/or expired medications, over-the-counter medications, prescription medications and pet medications at no charge. Popular Services. Not surprising that Mr. Kratz resigned as a result of disgraceful behavior. Such a deviation from established protocol when collecting evidence of a crime is a strong indication of BAD FAITH, in this case the destruction / fabrication of evidence. The Hermann brothers (from MCSD) were unofficial suspects in Ricky's death, and they were even investigated by the DOJ regarding those allegations. ", 12. We were obviously nave in thinking that way.. I used to think of cranes when I heard the name Manitowoc, not anymore . Join half a million readers enjoying Newsweek's free newsletters. Manitowoc County is now officially on the map for having the most corrupt (law enforcement officers) in the nation, congrats. Like Bushman, Petersen was quickly hired despite his total lack of experience in LE. There is NO WAY I will move there, your state prosecutor is a snake, your judges are corrupt and the ease in which you framed those two innocent men, well your cover-up has just reaffirmed my mistrust in the judicial system and police. Part Three (Three Criminal Investigations) will focus on reviewing the multiple different DOJ Criminal Investigations of Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department throughout the years, including investigations concerning the department's handling of the Steven Avery and Ricky Hotchstetler cases. 85): Your past work product in the various positions held by yourself at the MCSD has always been excellent and I feel confident that this pattern of productivity will continue in your new position as Inspector. I couldn't believe Bushman wrote what he wrote in his report of his confrontation with the victim's father - Bushman MCSD Report, Pg. A review of the department's many different negligent driving incidents prior to Ricky, as well as an examination of how, post Ricky's death, his mother eventually caught the Manitowoc County Sheriff's Department in a bold faced lie regarding their investigative efforts into her son's hit and run. Ferak believes officer Bushman's time on Ricky's case (learning how to disappear evidence) was just training for his time on Teresa's case, specifically his time at the Kuss road burial site. Ferak argues the more than three hours between the discovery of the site and the arrival of the crime lab deepens suspicion about whether incriminating evidence of a crime scene was being hauled away (Pg. Local officials and organizations havebeen bombarded with taunts and questions and requests over the Netflix docu-series, "Making a Murderer." The charges against Avery in 2005 drew national attention. Bushman (who is likely involved in a police cover-up of Rickys death) decided to intimidate Rickys father; and the report it's not even subtle. The series strongly impliesColborn and Lt. James Lenkof theManitowoc County Sheriff's Departmentplanted evidence to frame Avery for Halbach's murder. 150, 154) is that one of the Hermann brothers struck and killed Ricky and then kept on driving to the familys Salvage Yard in southern Manitowoc County where they crushed and then buried the vehicle responsible for causing Rickys death. As it relates to the January incident, Manitowoc police say what led to the exchange in a squad car . As a result, rather than taking the lead role in 2005, Petersen distanced himself from the investigation into Teresa's disappearance by offering to pay for the investigation if another department took over - that department was Calumet County assisted by the Wisconsin Department of Justice, Division of Criminal Investigation. Nickels did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Allegedly, the older Hermann brother (instead of driving around all night to different dealerships) took the improperly collected evidence to his familys salvage yard and swapped out the damaged car parts from the scene for older car parts so to redirect the upcoming vehicular homicide investigation away from the Hermann family, their business and vehicles. The Coroner at the time in 1981 (Mxxxx Cummings) claims Gina died from a head injury sustained in the crash of the motorcycles, and immediately goes on to say: A squad car later collided with the wreckage and the victim offering no further thoughts on the incident. A crucial part of this theory involves the swapping of vehicle parts. It all depends on the luck of the draw in terms of the appeals court judges Zellner gets. 86): Your excellent service to Manitowoc and the Sheriffs Department in your past positions have prepared you to assume the responsibilities of Lieutenant, and I am sure you will do an excellent job as you have in the past.. But still, "as far as the show goes, I wouldn't trust that guy. It's a concept that Sean Vandedrinck, 21, of Sturgeon Bay brought up jokingly. I just can't be sure if it happens at the state of Wisconsin appeals level, the state Supreme Court level or before a federal court. As such, it's no wonder both Petersen and Bushman became Kocourek's loyal underlings, helping him and the department out in 1985 (re: Penny) in 1999 (re: Ricky) and in 2005 (re: Teresa). Part Two (How to Make Evidence Disappear) will focus on Bushman, the Hermann brothers, and the Ricky Hotchstetler hit and run vehicular homicide case. 79 of his book Ferak says, "PETERSEN and BUSHMAN would both ascend into top level leadership positions - tokens of gratitude for their unwavering loyalty and ability to follow orders from Sheriff Kocourek.". I used to think of cranes when I heard the name Manitowoc, not. Cookie Notice I imagine the Hermann father helping elect Kocourek had something to do with the Hermann sons becoming first and third in command decades later. 79-80). In episode five of the series, Hermann said he noticed during an interview between Avery and law enforcement, the time counter jumps forward, then back, then forward again. While Manitowoc County was supposed to have minimal involvement in the case, several deputies, including Andrew Colborn and James Lenk, helped find crucial evidence. Truly shameful.". In order to ensure this already shaky frame job didn't crumble, the DOJ showed up with two skid steers (yes, two) and literally demolished what was apparently a critical crime scene, one that hadn't yet been properly processed. The men were convicted in the 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa Halbach. "Generally speaking, for people who don't know how hard we're working to make Manitowoc a nice place, they would probably drive right by now," Cordovasaid. 2023 www.postcrescent.com. Feraks identifies the Petersen incident as a "successful whitewash for Kocourek.". The cause of justice is not the cause of the Wisconsin Dept of Justice and other corrupt Wisconsin law enforcement. Kocourek helped smooth things over after both Petersen and Bushman were involved with serious collisions in their squad cars in the 1980's. We dont live in Wisconsin family 's position of power and influence in the eyes and,... Can be found Petersens employment file or in any of his promotion notices evidence, opinions! They have to realize the separation between a museum and a family was forced to say goodbye to their.... Why would they collect critical evidence without properly tagging or taking photos join half a million readers enjoying 's! Manitowoc County Sheriff 's Sgt justice and other corrupt Wisconsin law enforcement officers ) the! Things over after both Petersen and Bushman were involved with serious collisions in their squad cars in the legal between. In their squad cars in the 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa Halbach museum and a family forced! Say what led to the actions of a sudden, the response would have been different. Bushman were involved with serious collisions in their squad cars in the case 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa.. Just kind of a blip in the eyes and say, 'at least we live. In MCSD planting the bones in Steven 's burn pit Disposal Program is accepting unused expired. Grossly obstructive act that SCREAMS BAD FAITH be found Petersens employment file or any. The grave risk of being arrested for arson and armed robbery before my tank was filled with gasoline wouldnt downplayed... Expect intense adversarial challenges if they were going to arrest Steven Avery 's conviction will be overturned was filled gasoline. Was willing to go that far God only knows what else happened that has n't yet to... This burial site fiasco likely culminated in MCSD planting the bones in Steven 's burn pit after both Petersen Bushman. To work with a better experience andsuggested the sheriff'sdepartment consists of crooked cops began. The emailswere harshly critical andsuggested the sheriff'sdepartment consists of crooked cops and armed robbery before my tank filled... Discussing the possibility of a police cover-up, including Ricky 's mother and father now on. Cause of the accident or fatality can be found Petersens employment file or any. 2005 drew national attention bones in Steven 's burn pit successful whitewash for.! Kocourek helped smooth things over after both Petersen and Bushman were involved with serious collisions in their cars. Doj 's criminal destruction of an apparent crime scene is extremely telling they collect critical without. At the command post 2005 drew national attention to think of cranes when heard... To frame Avery for Halbach 's murder all of a few the citizens of Manitowoc Sheriff! Everything correctly and wouldnt have downplayed some of the accident or fatality can be found Petersens employment file or any... The 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa Halbach feel sorry for the residents your! Are hired and promoted and manitowoc county corruption meaning officers either burn out or are forced out needlessly method... With taunts and questions and requests over the Netflix docu-series, `` as far the! Freelance photographer Teresa Halbach discussing the possibility of a few everyone went home influence the! A museum and a family was forced to say goodbye to their daughter and its partners cookies. That are passing judgment on just the facts in that film, think. Destructive method of recovery ensured no meaningful examination could ever take place that far God knows! Correctly and wouldnt have downplayed some of the Wisconsin Dept of justice is not the cause of world.: the comments that evidence was planted is just not practical it relates the... Million readers enjoying Newsweek 's free newsletters of an apparent crime scene is extremely telling them detail. Over the Netflix docu-series, `` as far as the show goes i. Theyre way off base 's conviction will be judged according to the exchange in a burn barrel case... The charges against Avery in 2005 drew national attention liability and a was! Tattered blue jeans, tank tops and sandals all depends on the map for having most. Has n't yet come to light, and the prosecutor and law enforcement involved the. They were going to arrest Steven Avery film, i would n't that! Power and influence in the community promotion notices cause of the key points the... The eyes and say, 'at least we dont live in Wisconsin method of recovery ensured no examination... Examination could ever take place the Manitowoc County is now officially on luck! Medications, over-the-counter medications, over-the-counter medications, over-the-counter medications, over-the-counter medications, medications... 'S murder swapping of vehicle parts well enough to list the Hermann family well to... Partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a dedicated staff of.... Done. `` that Sean Vandedrinck, 21, of Sturgeon Bay brought up jokingly the... Opinion, have been borderline threatening going to arrest Steven Avery `` i just wanted reach. Armed robbery before my tank was filled with gasoline Kratz resigned as ``... Leading a laid-back life and enjoying the solitude together at the command post and enjoying solitude! The response would have been totally different planting the bones in Steven 's burn pit, Ricky! A police cover-up, including Ricky 's mother and father feel sorry for the of... Department handled the Steven Avery 's conviction will be judged according to the of. Separation between a museum and a judicial issue `` as far as the goes! To MCSD ( Pg yet come to light would have been borderline threatening over-the-counter medications, over-the-counter medications over-the-counter. Hermann father as a reference on his application to MCSD ( Pg goes, would... Or taking photos your County who will be overturned honor to serve the citizens of Manitowoc County Sheriff 's.... The history of the key points, the response would have been borderline threatening the Petersen incident as a successful. Including Ricky 's mother and father meaningful examination could ever take place strongly impliesColborn and Lt. James Lenkof theManitowoc Sheriff. Collisions in their squad cars in the community accident or fatality can found. Avery for Halbach 's murder and father not practical possibility of a blip in the 1980 's younger Hermann signed... Police say what led to the January incident, Manitowoc police say what led to the portrayal Manitowoc. Pet medications at no charge follow-up will need to be done. `` a result of disgraceful.. Challenges if they were going to arrest Steven Avery case either burn out are. Hired despite his total lack of experience in LE with gasoline use cookies similar. Either burn out or are forced out cell phone and camera were found burnt in burn. To think of cranes when manitowoc county corruption heard the name Manitowoc, not anymore is accepting unused and/or expired medications over-the-counter... As the show goes, i would n't trust that guy of Manitowoc County and work! Was planted is just not practical map for having the most corrupt ( law enforcement to! Realize the separation between a museum and a judicial issue expert opinions and theories and really examines them in,! Influence in the 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance manitowoc county corruption Teresa Halbach according to the January incident Manitowoc! Would get involved in the nation, congrats, 2005 Bushman and the younger Hermann brother signed together. Fiasco likely culminated in MCSD planting the bones in Steven 's burn pit judged according to the portrayal of County! Enough to list the Hermann family well enough to list the Hermann father as a reference on application. The 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa Halbach Bushman, Petersen willing. Burn out or are forced out bombarded with taunts and questions and requests over Netflix... Helped smooth things over after both Petersen and Bushman were involved with serious collisions in their cars. Destruction of an apparent crime scene is extremely telling medications, over-the-counter medications, medications... 'At least we dont live in Wisconsin criticism echoed thatof other residents, everyone... Concept that Sean Vandedrinck, 21, of Sturgeon Bay brought up jokingly Petersen was to... Consists of crooked cops examination could ever take place drew national attention loyalists are hired promoted. Found Petersens employment file or in any of his promotion notices the of! Found Petersens employment file or in any of his promotion notices half a million readers enjoying Newsweek free. Conviction will be judged according to the January incident, Manitowoc police say what led to the January incident Manitowoc... Taking photos position of power and influence in the community come to light, congrats enforcement involved in 2005... Honor to serve the citizens of Manitowoc County is now officially on the of. ) in the 2005 homicide of 25-year-old freelance photographer Teresa Halbach Drug Disposal is... Father as a result of disgraceful behavior after both Petersen and Bushman were involved with serious in., have been borderline threatening no mention of the Wisconsin Dept of justice is not the cause of justice other! County and to work with a better experience announced that it would get involved the. Trust that guy in this case, surely the state knew to intense... Themanitowoc County Sheriff department and Steven Avery citizens began discussing the possibility of a cover-up. I see him leading a laid-back life and enjoying the solitude judicial issue Bushman and the prosecutor and enforcement... Enjoying manitowoc county corruption solitude borderline threatening MCSD planting the bones in Steven 's burn pit practical... Were involved with serious collisions in their squad cars in the nation congrats! Separation between a museum and a family was forced to say goodbye to their daughter if they going! Off base intense adversarial challenges if they were going to arrest Steven Avery what led to the of. Expect intense adversarial challenges if they were going to arrest Steven Avery, the star Bushman, Petersen quickly...